RE LightGBM M3 and the retrospective audit of Italian public contracts

Which completed public contracts deserve a closer look when auditors can review only a small share of the files? RE LightGBM M3 addresses that question using Italian procurement records, administrative court decisions and selected grounds for contract closure. The research team has released the fitted decision trees, its rules for assigning labels and the scores from held-out contracts. In the published comparison, the highest-scoring one per cent contained roughly one fifth of the known positive cases. Yet the same model showed little ability to distinguish positive from negative outcomes across the labelled cases as a whole. This profile examines how both findings can hold, what a successful administrative appeal establishes, and what an audit authority would need to measure before using the ranking to allocate staff time. Its relevance lies in a question that the public evidence makes it possible to test.